Exploring Why Adding Water Enhances Whisky Flavor
Written on
Chapter 1: The Surprising Science Behind Whisky and Water
How do you prefer your whisky? Personally, I've long held a somewhat traditional stance: I enjoy my whisky neat—never with water or ice. The origins of this belief are unclear to me; perhaps it's a remnant of my time in Scotland, where I mistakenly thought that requesting a "wee drop of water" was blasphemy.
However, research offers a different perspective. In 2017, Swedish researchers Karlsson and Friedman published findings suggesting that adding water—up to a dilution of 27%—can actually enhance the flavor of whisky.
Section 1.1: Molecular Dynamics of Whisky
Karlsson and Friedman employed molecular simulations to analyze three essential components of whisky: ethanol, water, and guaiacol, a phenolic compound. Guaiacol contributes to the characteristic smokiness of whisky, especially in Scottish varieties.
At lower ethanol concentrations, molecules can arrange themselves at the whisky's surface, with their hydrophobic parts exposed to the air. Increasing the ethanol concentration forces these molecules deeper into the liquid. Since guaiacol prefers to bond with ethanol rather than water, the distribution of ethanol is crucial for flavor perception. A lower ethanol concentration—achieved through dilution—allows more guaiacol to rise to the surface, enhancing the whisky's flavor profile.
Subsection 1.1.1: Visual Representation of Molecular Interactions
Section 1.2: A Personal Experiment with Dilution
So, is it time for me to reconsider my whisky preferences? I decided to conduct a little experiment—though not the most rigorous. I poured a dram of one of my favorite Scottish whiskies (48% ABV, with notes of caramel, butter, and salt) and tasted it neat. While I appreciated the flavor, the ethanol was quite intense, making it difficult to savor the more herbal notes.
After adding a generous splash of water to mimic the dilution necessary for the ethanol and phenolic compounds to emerge, I was pleasantly surprised. The overwhelming ethanol was replaced by a more nuanced experience; I could finally detect subtle finishing notes, including a hint of mint.
Will I start diluting my whisky from now on? It's possible—I did appreciate the complexity of flavors that emerged. That said, the mouthfeel changed; my diluted dram lacked the viscous, oily texture I enjoy. Perhaps future tastings will involve comparing both neat and diluted whisky. After all, science demands exploration.
Chapter 2: Video Insights on Water and Whisky
The first video, "Adding Water to Whiskey - Dilution of Whiskey EXPLAINED," delves into the science of why water can elevate whisky's flavor profile.
The second video, "The Real Reason Why You Should Add Water To Your Whiskey," discusses the benefits of water addition in enhancing the whisky experience.