Unlocking Business Growth: Why Product-Channel Fit Matters
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Business Growth Dynamics
For a long time, I believed that achieving product-market fit was the sole requirement for business success. The prevailing notion was that once founders secured this fit, everything else would seamlessly fall into place. However, recent insights have significantly altered my perspective on growth in business. I wonder if they will change yours, too.
Brian Balfour, formerly the VP of Growth at HubSpot and now the founder of Reforge, a career advancement program for tech professionals, presents a compelling framework for understanding how businesses scale. He divides companies into two categories:
- Tugboats: Growth feels like pushing a ball uphill.
- Smooth Sailors: Growth resembles a ball rolling down a hill.
Balfour asserts that many businesses strive to become "Smooth Sailors" by fixating on "product-market fit," which he defines as how well a product meets the needs of its intended market.
You can recognize product-market fit by the rapid growth that typically follows. As Marc Andreessen, co-founder of the VC firm Andreessen Horowitz, puts it:
"You can always feel product/market fit when it's happening. The customers are buying the product just as fast as you can make it…Money from customers is piling up in your company checking account. You're hiring sales and customer support staff as fast as you can…Reporters are calling because they've heard about your hot new thing and they want to talk to you about it."
A classic example of product-market fit can be seen in Facebook's initial launch, which attracted over 22,000 photo views and 450 visitors within just four hours. The student directory (the product) clearly met the needs of Harvard students (the market), indicating early signs of product-market fit.
However, Balfour contends that product-market fit alone is insufficient for significant scaling. There are additional "fits" crucial for rapid growth, with "product-channel fit" being the most vital.
Section 1.1: Defining Product-Channel Fit
Balfour argues that a successful product must achieve both "product-market fit" and "product-channel fit." Here, "channel" refers to the methods used to drive traffic to your business, such as partnerships, search engine rankings, or paid advertisements.
The significance of product-channel fit lies in its ability to act as a multiplier for your business. You may possess an exceptional product that serves a substantial market, but without a means for consumers to discover your product, its potential is drastically diminished.
Example: TripAdvisor's Success Through Product-Channel Fit
TripAdvisor serves as an excellent illustration of a company that has secured both product-market fit and product-channel fit. As an independent platform, it shows clear signs of robust product-market fit, with users trusting its recommendations, travelers contributing numerous reviews, and travel agencies eager to partner.
However, the real key to TripAdvisor's success is its dominant position in Google search results. They consistently rank highly for location-related keywords, driving 52.9% of their traffic from Google.
Had TripAdvisor focused solely on product-market fit, they might have missed out on over half of their traffic. It's the synergy of their product and channel fit that propels their success.
The first video titled Corporate CPR Episode 102: How Lack Of Alignment Within Your Organization Might Be Stunting Growth delves into the importance of alignment in organizational structure and how it can impact growth.
Section 1.2: The Pitfalls of Ignoring Product-Channel Fit
Many founders err by treating product-market fit and product-channel fit as separate entities. A common mindset is:
"We're currently focusing on product-market fit. Once we achieve that, we will explore various channels."
Balfour warns against this approach, noting that products and channels are interconnected. The channel you choose influences product development decisions.
Subsection 1.2.1: Adapting Products for Channels
Products must be designed to align with channels, rather than the opposite. Each distribution channel has its own requirements that your product must fulfill to succeed. This means that understanding your preferred channel is critical, as it will shape the features of your product.
As Balfour explains:
"You do not define the rules of the channel. The channel defines the rules of the channel."
He further illustrates this with examples from platforms like Facebook, Google, and email clients, each dictating its own set of rules that impact how products should be constructed.
Chapter 2: Insights from the YouTube Community
A YouTuber with around 100k subscribers once advised me to consider the channels for content repurposing prior to filming. This advice underscores the importance of product-channel fit, where the video content (the product) must adapt to the specific platform (the channel).
For instance, YouTube favors longer, high-production-value content across various categories, while TikTok emphasizes shorter, entertaining videos targeted at a younger demographic.
Even though the underlying product (video) remains the same, you can't simply transfer content from YouTube to TikTok without making significant adjustments. This includes changes in shooting formats and editing styles to suit the platform's audience.
The second video titled Why Overlearning Is Stunting Your Growth discusses the drawbacks of excessive learning and its impact on personal growth.
The Power Law of Distribution Channels
Balfour presents a compelling argument for prioritizing product-channel fit over solely focusing on product-market fit. However, he introduces the concept of the "power law" in distribution channels, which suggests that a single channel often accounts for the majority of a company’s growth.
He cites Peter Thiel's book Zero to One:
"The kitchen sink approach [to testing channels] doesn't work. Most companies get zero distribution channels to work. If you get just one channel to work, you have a great business. If you attempt several but fail to excel in one, you’re done."
Balfour references examples like TripAdvisor, Yelp, Glassdoor, and Pinterest, which all derived 70% of their growth from user-generated SEO.
Should Founders Embrace a Shotgun Approach?
I find myself wrestling with the conclusion that founders should exclusively focus on one dominant channel. Initially, it’s difficult to determine which channel will become the primary one. Isn’t it necessary to experiment with multiple channels to discover the most effective one?
Moreover, relying on a single channel creates a risk. Algorithm changes, bans, or shifts in focus could drastically impact your business’s viability.
Though many companies may derive 70% of their growth from one channel, the other 30% is still significant. For instance, my newsletter has seen considerable growth from various sources, not just the primary channel.
Ultimately, while the power law is valid, the benefits of diversifying channels should not be overlooked.
What This Means for Your Business Strategy
Balfour's insights on product-channel fit challenge founders to broaden their focus beyond just product-market fit. Key takeaways include:
- Identify various channels for growth and start experimenting with them before finalizing your product.
- Consider how your chosen channels will influence the features of your product early in development.
- Once a successful channel is identified, allocate appropriate resources to nurture its growth.
As Twitch's founder Justin Kan aptly stated, "A first-time founder thinks about product. A second-time founder thinks about channels." Strive to be the second-time founder from the outset by prioritizing channels early on. This foresight could save you considerable frustration along the way. I'm cheering for your success!