Understanding the Limitations of Mental Health Labels
Written on
Chapter 1: The Allure of Therapy
In contemporary society, the idea of seeking therapy has gained significant traction. Many individuals are drawn to the notion of self-improvement, managing daily challenges, and addressing personal crises. This often leads to a simplistic explanation: “I’m this way because of a condition.” This perspective can make it feel as though the problem is resolved without any effort needed on their part. As common wisdom suggests, “If it’s beyond your control, there’s no need for concern.”
When you step into a therapist’s office, it seems to be exactly what you require. You can express your thoughts and feelings to a stranger who is detached, all while paying for this service. It feels like having a perfect friend who won’t judge you and who will solely focus on your issues. However, this idealized perception begins to unravel when an inner voice suggests, “This isn’t natural.” The therapist doesn’t truly know you; they only understand what you choose to share. Their view of you remains narrow and curated, lacking the depth of your everyday life. Consequently, the challenges you face may either be exaggerated or completely overlooked at crucial moments.
Historically, communities relied on elders or shamans who had established relationships within tight-knit groups. Today, when you arrive at a therapist’s practice, it’s often your first encounter. How can genuine healing occur with such a superficial connection? Even after numerous sessions, the relationship often stays at a surface level.
Certainly, therapists possess knowledge and wisdom that can guide you. Venting to someone outside your immediate circle can be beneficial, as it’s often more productive than bottling up emotions or fixating on negative past experiences. This might be the best alternative available for those without close friends or family to step into the role of a wise confidant. Yet, I believe this approach is only part of a larger solution. Integrating personal growth, which involves letting go of outdated beliefs that no longer serve you, is equally vital.
Section 1.1: The Dangers of Diagnosis
This is where the issue of labeling mental health disorders, often perpetuated by psychologists, becomes problematic. Competent psychologists recognize the limitations of various diagnoses outlined in the DSM-V and are cautious about assigning them indiscriminately, or at least hesitant when faced with pressure from clients. From a patient's viewpoint, seeking a diagnosis can seem logical—they desire a straightforward explanation for their struggles. However, life is rarely that uncomplicated. Attempting to classify the complexities of human psychology into rigid categories can be an appealing idea, but it lacks realism.
The criteria set forth in these classifications can appear deceptively precise: “If you meet 5 out of 8 criteria, you have this disorder.” However, that’s not how human experiences unfold. The interpretation of these criteria can vary significantly based on who is assessing them. The creators of the DSM-V may have different perspectives on these criteria compared to the countless psychologists interpreting them globally. Many individuals are consumed by the desire for labels like ASD, ADHD, or other conditions. They grapple with questions like, “Is it BPD/APD, or am I simply a flawed individual with poor moral standards?” Ultimately, this quest for a label may be in vain.
Section 1.2: A Shift Toward Functionality
Not every aspect of life can fit neatly into predefined categories. Therefore, I advocate for emphasizing healthy functioning. Many behaviors, particularly those related to mental health, can be detrimental. Whether it’s ADHD, ASD, or another concern, asking five different therapists could yield five unique perspectives. The crucial inquiry should be how we can enhance the functioning of individuals facing specific challenges—be it sensory issues, rumination, self-care, or daily tasks. This approach is likely to produce more effective outcomes than confining someone to predetermined criteria, which could inadvertently excuse them from taking responsibility for improvement.
The first video titled "Introduction to Psychology: Cautionary Tale of Labelling and Mental Illness" explores the implications of labels in mental health and how they can shape perceptions and experiences.
The second video, "Mental Health Difficulties - The Problem with Labelling People," delves into the challenges associated with labeling individuals and the potential harm it can cause in their healing journey.